YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING Reviewed by GREG KING
Documentary
Directors: Nathan Fielder, Lance Oppenheim

Experimental in nature, this unusual documentary from Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim follows Elizabeth Holmes, the founder of medical technology company Theranos who was jailed for eleven years on charges of fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit fraud and defrauding investors. Theranos was a private company founded in 2002 by the then 19-year-old Holmes. Holmes supposedly developed a new medical device that could detect illnesses from a single blood test.
Theranos raised some $700 million from donors and private equity firms and venture capitalists. Forbes magazine named Holmes as the youngest self-made billionaire in the US. But then she was indicted on several charges of fraud and conspiracy to commit fraud along with her business partner Ramesh Balwani. Holmes was sentenced to eleven years in prison.
In the 34 days before she begins her prison sentence, Holmes and her boy friend Billy Evans invited filmmaker Fielder (better known for his television comedies and his deadpan style) and Oppenheim and a film crew into her rented beach front home to record her every move. Throughout the film she maintains her innocence. Fielder himself is front and centre as he questions Holmes, trying to provoke a reaction from her, but his presence also raises some questions about his own lack of objectivity as he seems to become too personal. The film paints Holmes in a fairly sympathetic light.
There are a few scenes in which the camera lingers on Fielder’s face as he ponders Holmes’ answers and seeming evasions. He comes across as an awkward and unpolished interviewer. But there are also some scenes that sit uncomfortably – at one time Fielder shows Holmes some scenes from the 2022 television miniseries The Dropout, in which actress Amanda Seyfried played Holmes, hoping to provoke some reaction from her. In another largely unnecessary scene, he shows her the classic Abbott and Costello “Who’s on first?” routine, which she professes not to understand even though she laughs at the absurdity of it all.
Cinematographer David Bolen uses multi-camera set-up to capture the interactions from a number of perspectives. He also works in extreme close-up for much of the time (a technique he also used in Oppenheim’s drama Primetime) and the film becomes claustrophobic and uncomfortable but also surprisingly intimate. Ari Balouzian’s vaguely menacing electronic score creates an uneasy atmosphere that perfectly suits the enigmatic mood of the film.
The first half of this near three-hour documentary is repetitive and troubling, and I sometimes found my mind wandering. But the second half, set two years after Holmes has begun to serve her sentence in a minimum-security women’s prison in Texas, takes us down a rabbit hole and the film blurs the line between pure documentary and docudrama. In a meta move, Fielder recruits Seyfried to again play Holmes as he stages many re-enactments of interactions that he was unable to film, including a meeting in the prison meeting room with Holmes. In the reenactments Billy is portrayed by actor Christopher Abbott (who starred opposite Seyfried in The Testament Of Ann Lee). Seyfried herself questions some of Holmes’ decisions and even questions Fielder’s actions.
Fielder reveals that when meeting with himself and Oppenheim and executives from production company A24 Billy himself raised the issue of accessing a share of the profits from the movie, which raises questions about his motivation – is he involved in a search for truth or is he merely in it for the money? Billy has also gained power of attorney over Holmes’ public image, allowing him to control her social media sites and post material in her name. He has also started a new company Haemanthus, but the enterprise seems shady as he refuses the allow Fielder to question one of the company’s employees about what technology they are using.
In fact, I felt that I learned more about Billy than Holmes from this documentary. Billy comes across as narcissistic, manipulative, controlling and slightly sleazy, while the enigmatic Holmes appears more naïve and disingenuous. The filmmakers don’t provide enough background detail and context about Holmes. Despite the title there is a sense that there is a lot more yet to be revealed.
Morally ambiguous, ethically challenging and deeply troubling at times, You Can See Everything is overrated, overlong (with a bloated running time of 172 minutes), self-indulgent and repetitive. It could have been trimmed to make it more accessible, effective and compelling.
However, since being released You Can See Everything has been widely acclaimed, and it is even tipped to win an Oscar.
★★★☆



